I did mine at 54/55 I didn’t want to wait for other issues with other toes. I’m glad I did mine and wishes I did it earlier.
Community discussion
Question for those of you who say you’d never do this surgery again because recovery was much harder than…
Question for those of you who say you’d never do this surgery again because recovery was much harder than expected… What was the alternative for you? I’m struggling with the “pay now or pay later” thought process. I have hypermobility, a partially torn plantar plate, and I’m almost 60. Part of me worries that waiting another 10–20 years could mean things progress further and recovery becomes even harder later in life. So how do you decide whether to roll the dice and manage it conservatively, or bite the bullet while you still have good home support, decent health, and insurance? I’ve already modified my lifestyle for nearly 10 years. I’m fortunate that I don’t have to wear restrictive shoes for work, I wear orthotics, and I’ve adapted around it pretty well. I’m not in severe pain (but I have limited my walking/hiking etc), which is what makes this decision harder. For those who chose to delay or skip surgery, what was the payoff? Did it actually stay manageable long term, or do you wish you had done it sooner?
Archived from Bunion Surgery / Foot Surgery Support. View the original discussion on Facebook (sign-in may be required).
The visible discussion was fully captured at the time of collection.
Need to ask which procedure they had. Not all MIS procedures are the same. Some fuse others don’t. Some have you non-weight bearing for weeks others don’t. Some procedures have large scars. Others don’t.
I wish I had been able to do it sooner. I’m happy with my results.
Check out lapiplasty surgery- if your bunion hasn’t gotten huge. It’s probably better to have your metatarsal rotated back where it belongs so that you.sesamoid Bones sit underneath your foot where they’re supposed to
I put off my surgery for about 20 years as I couldn't face being out of action during recovery. Eventually my foot got so bad I had to go through with the surgery (November last year) and unfortunately it wasn't 100% successful so I need further surgery to reposition my big toe and make it lie flat, so I'll be having that later this year. Perhaps if I'd had the surgery sooner it may have been successful the first time.
The first 4 weeks were super tough for me. I’m at 8 weeks and feeling soooo much better! I would say I am at 75%. Still some swelling and some discoloration but the dr says it can take 6-12 months to be fully recovered. I was second guessing myself for the first 4 weeks though, It was rough! Now that I’m on the other side of that, I am looking to have my other foot done in Nov/Dec.
I have hyper mobility so had to have that fixed as well so the bunion didn’t return . I am nearly three weeks post op and it has been rough , slowly it’s getting a bit better . You just have to be prepared that it’s a long recovery . I am the same as you I love hiking and exercising so put it off, but it was getting painful not on the bunion on my toes, that’s why I made the decision to have the operation . I had left it far too long and I had stopped wearing sandles as I was embarrassed they way my feet looked. I think this site is great for support but I am glad I didn’t find it before my op as I think I would have been put off with some of the stories
It’s a very personal decision. If you’re in pain- get multiple opinions from different surgeons until you find one who makes you comfortable (or none). They’ll all have a different approach
I had bunion surgery 18 months ago that failed. Currently 3.5 months post fusion surgery. If I could go back in time, I would have thrown away all my cute shoes and worn wide toe box sensible shoes. If that didn’t work, I would have gone to an orthopedic surgeon instead of a podiatrist. The recovery from the fusion with an orthopedic surgeon was a cake walk in comparison. The NWB is awful, but no pain
Together with the akin and scarf osteotomy for my bunion, the surgeon performed a failed Weill 2,3 osteotomy, overshortened my mtp 2 and 3. Ik would never give permission again for thé torture bankscrew procedure called Weill. The surgeon only mentioned floating toes as a complication. Turns out his definition of floating toes is painfull floating hamertoe ! I had a painfree slightly floating second toe which is I found out afterward a serious contra indication. Now I have two painfull floating hamertoes. The joints still look red and Blue 8,5 months post-op My foot felt like being in a very painfull bankscrew when lowering it thé first 4,5 months. Around week 8 painfull pinching started in thé Weill scar followed by very painfull knife stabbing in the shortened bones. It feels like each month a new complication arises due tot this unnessary torture procedure that did not solve anything, but only caused more severe problems. It did not solve the recurring synovial cyste near the flexor tendon from my third toe. The extra's are dorsal fibrose (when putting my foot down, thé surgical area is one block of concrete, pulling my 2nd and 3rd toe up) that worsens painfully 2 months after cortisone injection (my painmeds Medikinet no longer work against thé pinching and knife stabbing pain) and for which 38 sessions of PT did nothing, pinching and knife stabbing, toe cramps where all 5 toes and balk of my foot turn upwards until It van crack something mid foot, global osteopeen bonepattern, pain going up towards midfoot from the Weill scar, sharp pain underneath the ball of my foot (suspected plantar plate year die to bones sticking out underneath the ball/fat pad of my foot, minimale artrose of midfoot none and anckle die to wait shifting go thé backdoor from overshortening, twisted anckle feeling on top of my forefoot, screws feel like they are srewed in 2 to 3 times to tight. My surgeon told me he does this procedure with 30% of his patients and 2/3 of them have painfull floating toes 6 months post-op. I have tested lyrica 2 days which where hellish for my husband and family. Lyrica amplifies my anger (for the renomated surgeon who ruined my forefoot and who lied to me and my husband not once, but during several post-op consultations) so much that my family only gets very angry replies and all i can think about while on lyrica is that I can not eat anything anymore. Orthotics have been adjusted 3 times and I still can not tolerate them. Now my own dr has prescribed fenytoine crème 5% artisanale made by thé pharmacy. I hope that works against the pinching and knife stabbing pain. My appointment with thé professor known for his critical viewing of other surgeons surgeries is only in about 2,5 months. Though I would like for the screws to be removed now, it's better to wait until it can be done together with a complete reversion of the Weill to avoid creating 2 x extra scar tissue.
did you have a lot of pain?
what were your symptoms prior to surgery?
After
I took pain pills and muscle relaxer and Tylenol and advil like clockwork for 2 days. I made sure I always iced, and elevated, walked, and slept with my after surgery boot. That was the info I was discharged with. I only took it off occasionally during icing and bathing. I had one for inside my house and one for outside.
before
my feet got wider and my toes started shifting where I was nervous if they went over the 2nd toe it would mean more type of surgery. I’ve always had them but managed it, ingrown toe nails and soreness. When they started shifting even more than before I got nervous
good point, true. For mine they want to fuse and repair plantar plate so I guess that is my guide post.
is that a big toe fusion?
lapidus
Lapidus is a fusion.
yes, yes it is.
what did they do to correct your hypermobility?
This is what I had done With the flat feet and the hypermobility, it would he quite difficult to correct these deformities reliably and avoid the high risk of recurrence, so my thoughts are we would do a Lapidus procedure to fuse the 1st TMT joint, slightly plantar flex and correct the IMA, thereby hopefully reducing the risk of recurrence and treating the hypermobility at the TMT joint at the same time. We will correct the bunion and will do a 2nd toe PIP and a 3rd toe DIP fusion with k-wires
thank you. I had a triple fusion on my left ankle for hypermobility. It was so painful! I hope not to have to go through another one. 😬
why do you do I dip procedure on the third toe?
I’ve stopped wearing cute shoes 10 years ago, will that stop it from progressing? I don’t want to do a surgery at 70 or 80, when does the risk outweigh the benefit? What did you like better about the orthopedic doctor vs the podiatrist ?
the podiatrist botched the bunion surgery and had lots of pain. The ortho fixed it and no pain. Just still dealing with swelling but that’s normal because I’m 60
I think the key is wide toe box
I'm so sorry Mady. It sounds like you're in a lot of pain. My first surgery caused a lot of scar tissue and I ended up with shortening of toes 2,3 and 4. It really lessens your ability to balance. I've been in this postoperative condition for 6 years and my whole body has suffered from the limping. I'm praying I can have another surgery to repair it somewhat. Foot surgeries can really impact your life in a negative way. I don't go out socially and only manage best as I can to take care of myself. I'll pray for both of us to find a compassionate surgeon who will help us. I am 74 so I have lost some goods years but now the lack of activity is affecting the circulation in my legs. I really need some pain relief so I can be more mobile. Hope your upcoming appointment is helpful 🙏🪧


Community replies
29 in this archive